Public Debate

Learners research the pros and cons of the Clyde Waterfront being be used for public transport and, in two groups, write an argument which will be presented in a public debate. These lessons will develop a k/u of transport on the Clyde waterfront allowing learners to argue their case for or against public transport on the Clyde. After researching water transport and the Clyde, learners will write their argument, organised logically, using their research as supporting evidence, discussing the features of a debate. Debate will then be held with parents as the audience, who will be able to ask questions at the end.

Broad Outcomes of learning
• Subject knowledge gained and advanced e.g. knowledge of the structure of an argument as well as increased knowledge of the waterfront and transport
• Enterprising skills improved by developing confidence, taking responsibility and making decisions; consideration of others through group work and discussion
• Developed employability skills: communication, planning, researching, co-operating, contributing, reporting, presenting, negotiating and debating
• Confidence of working independently from teacher-led lessons demonstrated by taking control of their research and using this to find their own answer to the debate question then working in teams to devise a winning argument
• Pupils take responsibility for their learning through making decisions about where they stand in the debate, the level of research they need to do, choosing the best order for their arguments, inviting parents and taking part in or leading the debate
• Pupils have developed 4 capacities of CfE
Relevance to curriculum
• Supports CfE Languages

Learners research the pros and cons of the Clyde Waterfront being be used for public transport and, in two groups, write an argument which will be presented in a public debate. These lessons will develop a k/u of transport on the Clyde waterfront allowing learners to argue their case for or against public transport on the Clyde. After researching water transport and the Clyde, learners will write their argument, organised logically, using their research as supporting evidence, discussing the features of a debate. Debate will then be held with parents as the audience, who will be able to ask questions at the end.

Broad Outcomes of learning

  • Subject knowledge gained and advanced e.g. knowledge of the structure of an argument as well as increased knowledge of the waterfront and transport
  • Enterprising skills improved by developing confidence, taking responsibility and making decisions; consideration of others through group work and discussion
  • Developed employability skills: communication, planning, researching, co-operating, contributing, reporting, presenting, negotiating and debating
  • Confidence of working independently from teacher-led lessons demonstrated by taking control of their research and using this to find their own answer to the debate question then working in teams to devise a winning argument
  • Pupils take responsibility for their learning through making decisions about where they stand in the debate, the level of research they need to do, choosing the best order for their arguments, inviting parents and taking part in or leading the debate
  • Pupils have developed 4 capacities of CfE

Relevance to curriculum

  • Supports CfE Languages

 

Download this lesson/project idea
Transport Support Materials
  • Transport Support Materials
  • Get ADOBE Reader